Properties

San Diego, CA 92116 4457 North Ave

Pending
4457 North Ave San Diego, CA - Image 14457 North Ave San Diego, CA - Image 24457 North Ave San Diego, CA - Image 3
7 more
4457 North Ave San Diego, CA - Image 44457 North Ave San Diego, CA - Image 54457 North Ave San Diego, CA - Image 64457 North Ave San Diego, CA - Image 74457 North Ave San Diego, CA - Image 84457 North Ave San Diego, CA - Image 94457 North Ave San Diego, CA - Image 104457 North Ave San Diego, CA - Image 11
Presented By: Blake Tagmyer with Cushman & Wakefield of San Diego, Inc;
  • MLS# 260004238SD
  • 02/23/2026
  • Get pre-approved
  • Request Tour
  • Request Info
  • Baths • 1

Home Details

Pleased to present 4457โ€“63 North Avenue, a rare 4-unit cottage-style multifamily opportunity in the heart of University Heights offering stable in-place income with significant long-term redevelopment upside. Situated along North Ave in one of San Diegoโ€™s most supply-constrained, walkable neighborhoods, the Property provides immediate access to Park Blvd and Adams Ave dining, retail, and nightlife corridors. Residents are minutes from Hillcrest, North Park, Downtown San Diego, and Balboa Park, with convenient access to I-8, SR-163, and I-805. The asset comprises four detached and semi-detached bungalow-style residences plus approximately 880 SF of built-in garage space. The layout includes a primary house (~788 SF), two 480 SF one-bedroom duplex units, and one additional cottage arranged around expansive yard space, creating a single-family feel uncommon in dense infill locations. Rear alley access serves four built-in garages, a rare amenity in this parking-constrained submarket. Well-maintained with clear value-add potential, investors can capture mark-to-market rent growth through interior and exterior upgrades and operational optimization while preserving the Propertyโ€™s character. The site is underpinned by RM-2-5 zoning with a CCHS Tier 2 designation permitting up to 8.0 FAR, allowing approximately 56,000 buildable SF. Located within a Transit Priority Area, future development may benefit from reduced or eliminated parking requirements. Additionally, the existing improvements allow for potential ADU additions prior to full redevelopment.
Presented By: Blake Tagmyer with Cushman & Wakefield of San Diego, Inc;

Interior Features for 4457 North Ave

Bathrooms

Total Baths

Other Interior Features

Air Conditioning Y/NNo
Heating Y/NYes
Total Stories2

General for 4457 North Ave

Cap Rate2.89
CitySan Diego
CoolingNone
CountySan Diego
DirectionsCrossStreet: North Ave & Meade Ave
HOA Fee$
LevelsTwo
Listing TermsCash, Conventional, Cal Vet Loan, FHA
MLS Area92116 - Normal Heights
Net Operating Income47706
Number Of Units Total4
PostalCitySAN DIEGO
Property TypeResidential Income
RoofComposition
Senior Community Y/NNo
Standard StatusPending
StatusPending
Stories Count2
Subdivision NameUniversity Heights
Tenant PaysCable TV, Electricity, Gas, Water
Virtual TourClick here
Year Built1920

Exterior for 4457 North Ave

Lot Size SourcePublic Records
Number of Buildings3
Park NameNA
SpaNo
Total Parking0

Additional Details

Price History

Schools

High School Hubert H Humphrey Middle School
Middle School N/A
Elementary School Big Hollow Elementary School

Connect Realty

Price $1,650,000
MLS#260004238SD
List Date 02/23/2026
Property Type Multi-Family
Phone 888.795.6274
Get pre-approved
Request Tour
Request Info
Visit My Website

Similar Properties to 4457 North Ave

Contact Us

info@connectrealty.com
2170 Buckthorne PL. #100
The Woodlands, TX 77380
866-938-0924
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.